I'd go with the tirerack.com reviews. The BF Goodrich Advantage received a higher rating in only one category, wear. In all other categories the Quatrac 5 had the highest ratings of all the "Grand Touring All Season" tires.
The BF Goodrich does have a higher UTOG (however, this might be somewhat suspicious as manufacturers assign their own ratings).
2017 CX-3 GT, AWD, i-ActiveSense, Ceramic Metallic, Black ... His: Zoom, Zoom!
2016 HR-V EX-L, AWD, Milano Red, Black ... Hers: Putt, Putt.
Last edited by mainemanx; 07-27-2018 at 03:20 PM.